, Decision_act (EU) 1996/76

In forcesince 4 Oct 1995
(3)

Article 92 adds that other aid may be compatible with the common market. Compatibility must be determined in the context of the Community and not of a single Member State. In order to safeguard the proper functioning of the common market and, taking into account the principles of Article 3 (g) of the EC Treaty, the exceptions to the principle set out in Article 92 (1) to be found in Article 92 (3) must be construed narrowly when scrutinizing any aid scheme or individual award.

In particular, the Commission has for the motor vehicle industry adopted Community guidelines setting out the criteria for assessing the compatibility with the common market of State aid to this industry, thereby limiting the scope of discretion under point (c) of Article 92 (3).

As explained above and in the opening of the procedure, the Commission is convinced that both aid measures were notifiable under the motor vehicle industry guidelines, which were in operation at the time of the aid award (1990, 1991 and 1992). The Commission has therefore to consider whether these aid measures were compatible with the assessment criteria of those guidelines.

While the region of South East Brabant where the plant of DAF is located in the Netherlands has recently been considered by the Commission as an Objective 2 area, the area was at the time the aid was granted (1990, 1991 and 1992) not a regionally assisted area within the meaning of points (a) or (c) of Article 92 (3) of the EC Treaty nor can any of these aid measures be considered as having a regional objective.

As regards the Fl 1,55 million advance to a notified but not approved R& D aid, the Commission has obtained evidence that DAF NV, before its receivership, spent Fl 18,3 million on a project known as Volem (accelerated development of low emission engines) which according to its motor expert contains sufficient elements of pre-competitive research to justify the level of aid actually paid. This concerns, in particular, the research relating to the study of air flow of the engine by using mathematical computer models with visual display of air flow rigs. Therefore, this grant is in conformity with the guidelines for assessment of R& D aid of the guidelines on State aid to the motor vehicle industry and thus satisfies the conditions for the application of the exception provided in point (c) of Article 92 (3).