whether a TOK loan is repayable depends on the commercial success of the products developed by the aided project. This instrument is approved by the Commission. If the project fails there is no aid since there is no product which can distort the competition and if the project succeeds there is no question of aid either because interest is charged until the loan is fully repaid. In fact, since the part of the TOK loan which relates to the costs made for the F 80, which failed, has not been remitted, as it could have been under the rules of a TOK loan, the company even has to repay more since it has to repay the entire loan, relating to the F 80 and the F 95, and this only with the profits of the F 95. Relating the repayment to the profits offers more control possibilities and was decided after long discussions with DAF NV. As regards securities, it is unusual to ask for securities for TOK loans since they involve risky projects and it is only when commercial borrowers are reluctant to finance a project that companies apply for a TOK loan.
With regard to the latest TOK loan, NML (Nieuwe Medium Line)-TOK, awarded in 1991, and increase with a second tranche in 1992, the Dutch government argued that:
this TOK loan concerned innovative products. Detailed information was provided to prove that the new medium truck series (DAF 75/85) were innovative products in the truck market,
the company was suffering losses at that time but DAF was listed on the stock exchange and had effected a successful share issue. As far as the loan increase in July 1992 is concerned, the Netherlands argued that even at that time they had no doubts about the continuity of the company because the long-term prospectives were good. It was only in November 1992 that the first signals emerged concerning DAF's solvency problems. After that, events moved very fast,
the Dutch authorities further argued that they might recover the amount paid of Fl 33,5 million plus interest charges as they have registered it as an unsecured debt with the receivers of DAF NV.
As regard the research subsidy of Fl 1,55 million, the Dutch government argued that:
this first payment was made subject to approval of the notified aid by the Commission. It corresponded to 80 % of the aid proposed in respect of research expenditure effected prior to mid-1992. For further research realized until the receivership DAF did not receive any advance,