the fixed settlement price (407 million) is higher than the liquidation value (256,8 million), but lower than the fair market value on a going concern basis (498,075 million). The selling price is a fair price, otherwise the independent receivers would not have sold at that price and the judge would not have approved the transfer. Moreover, under the Dutch legal system, the Dutch State cannot exert any influence on the receivers. The price obtained is a fair price obtained after commercial negotiations and it has to be taken into account that DAF's position was deteriorating. Furthermore, the secured creditors have to agree with the purchase price while the receivers decide in the interest of the non-secured creditors. The valuation reports by independent appraisers and the assessment made by the receivers of the purchase price in the light of this valuation exclude the possibility of any aid element.
The position of the Dutch State was further reinforced by their legal advisers and the receivers of DAF NV who argued that under Dutch bankruptcy law:
the winding up of DAF NV and the related asset transaction took place in accordance with current Dutch law on company winding-up. Dutch law affords the receivers freedom regarding the method of sale but private sales are generally given preference. So, by taking the initiative to find a buyer, the receivers of DAF NV acted within the law,
only the secured and not the unsecured creditors have to give their consent to a sales agreement so that the Dutch State as an unsecured creditor could not have blocked the sales agreement,
a company in the course of creation can legitimately be a party to a sales agreement and such an agreement - even being oral and not fully complete and not yet approved by the supervisory judge - has legal binding effects on all the parties concerned so that the Dutch State, at the time it was informed about a possible higher offer, could not have withdrawn from such an agreement. The receivers were also bound by the agreement of 20 February 1993, so that they were no longer free to enter into negotiations concerning the offer of Klesch & Company which had simply come too late and was subject to contract,