, Decision_act (EU) 1996/76

In forcesince 4 Oct 1995
–

illegal aid was awarded through this TOK loan since it had not been notified. This TOK loan enabled the company to renew its model range at a time when it would not have been possible to finance such expenditure entirely from its own resources or other external borrowings,

–

TOK loans represent an approved aid system which does not only contain State aid in case of failure but also in case of success given that they are awarded at an interest rate below the market rate and the interest is compounded to the capital without charging compound interest. The Commission values the aid given on the date of receivership as Fl 35 990 000 constituted by Fl 33 489 000 principal and Fl 2 501 000 interest charges. This includes the interest advantage obtained by the company between the award of the aid and the date of receivership, using the reference rate by which the net grant equivalent of regional aid in the Netherlands is calculated. The fact that the Dutch State only requests reimbursement from the bankrupt company DAF NV of Fl 35 597 000, leaves an amount of Fl 393 000 which constitutes the abovementioned additional aid element of the loan,

–

granting a new TOK loan in 1991 was not economically justified since DAF already faced difficulties in the repayment of the first TOK loan. The repayment of the older loan had to be made in years of profitability of the company; the reimbursement of any new TOK loan would necessarily affect that profitability in the future, thus jeopardizing the recovery of the old loan,

–

as far as the increase of the NML-TOK loan of July 1992 is concerned, this was even more questionable since it had been granted at a time of severe financial difficulties for the company, which went into receivership half a year later.

As regards the research subsidy of Fl 1,55 million, this amount was paid as an advance to aid, outside any approved system, which was notified to the Commission for approval. As such, it clearly constitutes State aid as it alleviated the company from part of its normal R& D expenditure.

With regard to the postponement by the NIB on the first repayment of Fl 2,5 million on a loan of Fl 30 million, the Commission shares the point of view of the Dutch authorities that the Dutch State did not act differently than other unsecured creditors of DAF NV. Therefore, this instalment of a public loan which was not reimbursed by DAF NV before the receivership does not constitute State aid.

  • case:eu=C-3/92