The Commission agrees that the direct-current arc technology itself is established, and consequently it does not consider the electric arc furnace to be eligible for State aid (see below). One of the aims of the project is the recycling of iron and not of zinc, as stated in the observation. Bispa remarks that it is not clear how the post-combustion relates to the use of non-shredded car scrap. In order to find this out, the demonstration project has to be undertaken.
EISA:
The Commission agrees that electric arc furnaces are used for the manufacture of special steels. This, however, is not the object of the R & D. Post-combustion itself is known, but here it has to be demonstrated that this can lead to lower emission of dioxin. To achieve this, the functioning of a combination of techniques developed by Kloeckner and L'Air Liquide has to be demonstrated.
As far as the blowing of the iron dust through hollow electrodes is concerned, Eisa remarks that so far this technique has been unable to deal with large quantities. It is the aim of the R & D to establish whether this is true.
MEFOS:
The Commission takes note of the fact that this research institute has nothing against the realization of the project. It emphasizes however that Georgsmarienhuette is already half-way to demonstrating the actual functioning of the technology of blowing ferrous dust through a hollow electrode and that the project in Norway is still under discussion.
Usinor Sacilor:
The Commission agrees that the technology of the electric arc furnace is established. The blowing of iron dust through a hollow electrode presents no industrial risk according to Usinor Sacilor, since the conversion to a normal type of electric arc furnace is very easy, if the technology proves unsatisfactory. This means, however, that it still has to be investigated whether the technology is satisfactory. Furthermore, Usinor Sacilor acknowledges that the use of non-shredded car scrap in a single-step process could be innovative. It has to be remarked that the aim of this part of the R & D is to combine several techniques in order to reduce the emission of dioxin and furan. The Commission agrees that the manufacture of special steels by a direct current arc furnace does take place; but this is not the object of the R & D.
Government of the United Kingdom: