The German authorities gave their reaction to those observations by letter of 24 June 1994. They discuss the observations by the other parties in detail and they repeat their opinion that the whole project constitutes research and development. To answer the criticisms, it is conceded that neither a DC arc furnace nor a hollow electrode is new. However, the dust injection is not performed during the production of steel but outside the time when steel is produced. Furthermore, a separation of Zn and Pb from the dust is not the objective of the process, as it is for existing technologies, but the dust is converted to a raw material than can be used instead of scrap in future steel production. Another aspect of the R & D is to render harmless certain gases that result from the extra energy fed into the smelting bath. Car bodies contain lacquers and oils and fats. When melted these sub-products produce extra energy and dioxin and furan, both toxic gases. Through the post-combustion phase these gases will be broken down. An optimal use of all the energy carriers with the appearance of a minimum of toxic gases should therefore become possible. With the cooperation of L'Air Liquide a tangential injection of oxygenous gases will be demonstrated which allows a good blending and a high degree of burning of the gases. It is expected that this will lead to energy-saving as well.
By letter of 11 July 1994, the German authorities informed the Commission of a modification of the costs connected to the R & D project. Because of the erosion and consumption of certain materials and equipment in the R & D project, which will be carried out on two days a week over 51 months, extra costs have to be incurred. These costs arise when blowing iron-bearing dust through the hollow electrode, and they break down as follows:
>TABLE>
The German authorities considered these costs to be eligible for R & D aid of DM 3,45 million (ECU 1,79 million). This represents an aid intensity of 25 %.