, Decision_act (EU) 1995/437

In forcesince 1 Feb 1995

By letter of 21 June 1994, those letters and their translated versions plus Annexes were sent to the German Permanent Representation.

The German Government replied by letter of 24 June 1994, registered the same day. An informal meeting between representatives of the Commission and the German Government took place in Brussels on 30 June 1994.

By letters of 11 July and 26 October 1994, the German authorities brought fresh information to the attention of the Commission.

II

The investment project includes the construction of a direct-current electric arc furnace to replace the existing blast furnace and converter. The aim of the investment is - according to the German Government - the environmentally-friendly use of iron-bearing waste materials (in particular 'iron dusts` and non-shredded car scrap), with the object of reducing production costs.

The German Government claims that this will be the first time that this type of furnace is used for large-scale production of quality and special steels.

In particular, the new furnace provides the introduction of a (single) hollow electrode, through which iron-bearing dusts resulting from iron and steel production together with carbon can be injected into the steel production process.

Further, a post-combustion of CO gases within the furnace and a corresponding anode-regulation will ensure that non-shredded car scrap can be economically recycled in an environmentally-friendly manner and in a one-step process.

Investment cost considered eligible by the German Government for State aid amounted to DM 108,2 million (ECU 57,1 million) and comprised the following items:

>TABLE>

III

The investment cost of DM 108,2 million (ECU 57 million) considered eligible by the German Government and other costs related to the project totalling DM 16,3 million (ECU 8,6 million) were to be financed as follows:

>TABLE>

The Commission had doubts, as expressed in the opening of the procedure pursuant to Article 6 (4) of the SAC, on the following points:

–

the genuine R & D character of the project,

–

the eligibility of the investment costs for R & D aid proposed,

–

the inclusion of costs that are not eligible for R & D aid under any circumstances,

–

the resulting aid intensity of 30 %. Owing to the high risk of the project, according to the reasoning set out in the notification, the intensity should be 30 % instead of 25 % which is the intensity normally acceptable to the Commission for applied R & D.

IV