, Decision_act (EU) 1995/437

In forcesince 1 Feb 1995

No arguments have been given that endorse the view that there is no original research. However, the Commission considers on the basis of the arguments put forward that there is evidence of R & D.

Costs that are incurred directly as a result of the R & D project are eligible for State aid for R & D.

In the context of this case, this means that certain costs cannot be considered eligible for R & D State aid.

>TABLE>

These costs are not incurred as a result of the R & D project and bear no direct relation to the R & D project as a whole or with any of the sub-projects. These costs are in fact industrial investment costs and they have to be made by the company in order to produce the products for the market.

On the other hand, the direct costs arising from the R & D projects are eligible for R & D State aid. These projects are:

>TABLE>

The costs of the injection of iron-bearing dust was raised by DM 1 million over the figure given in the notification because of the longer duration of the project.

Apart from these costs, that cover equipment and materials necessary for the projects, the following costs are also incurred directly by the R & D work:

>TABLE>

As far as the general expenses are concerned, they are calculated as 30 % of the personnel costs. Georgsmarienhuette has demonstrated that over the past years such a percentage is reasonable and in conformity with its normal ratio between personnel costs and general expenses.

DM 108,2 million was originally notified as eligible for R & D aid. On the basis of the extension of the duration of the R & D project from 36 months to 51 months, DM 1,65 million (including 30 % of extra personnel costs for general expenses) was added to this amount, giving DM 109,85 million.

However, certain costs are not incurred directly as a result of the R & D project and they have to be deducted from the amount:

>TABLE>

For certain of these costs the German authorities proposed to grant aid with an intensity of 30 % and for one, the scientific cooperation with the TU Clausthal and the University of Patras, of 50 %.

However for applied research and development, the Commission has adopted the practice of allowing only 25 % gross. In cases of high specific risk a higher aid level may be considered by the Commission.