, Decision_act (EU) 1995/437

In forcesince 1 Feb 1995

EISA EISA expressed doubts as to the R & D nature of parts of the project and of the feasibility of others, in particular as to the scope of the project. The processes of post combustion in arc furnaces have already been researched. The use of hollow electrodes has already been applied to other kinds of dust. EISA concludes that it regards the method described as problematic for mass-production purposes.

MEFOS Mefos stated that the technology of feeding ferrous dust through a hollow electrode is already developed and known. Its objective has been to allow steel plant dust to be used economically. The project has come so far that discussions have started with a view to forming a production company in Norway together with a zinc producer. Regarding post-combustion in the electric arc furnace much development work had been performed. Mefos had nothing against the realization of the project.

Usinor Sacilor Usinor Sacilor is of the opinion that the project is entirely based on already known technologies and that the aid is consequently only for investment purposes. It was especially worried that investment aid for the construction of a new arc furnace was being presented as aid for R & D purposes.

Government of the United Kingdom The United Kingdom authorities are convinced that the plant will be a full-scale commercial operation from the outset, since it replaces the existing iron and steelmaking facilities on the site and there if no evidence of any valid R & D activities associated with the construction of the DC furnace. They therefore consider that any State finance provided would constitute illegal aid pursuant to Article 4 of the ECSC Treaty and under secondary legislation.