, Decision_act (EU) 1994/290

In forcesince 27 Apr 1994

Secondly, the measure is apparently neither objective nor consistent. It is, first of all, based solely on Member States' national frontiers and not based on duly established criteria which could warrant this choice of national frontiers as its basis. The reason: since 1 January 1993 national frontiers as such are no longer among the objective criteria for deciding the distribution of intra-Community traffic within an airport system, because Regulation (EEC) No 2408/92 aims specifically to establish an internal market as 'an area without internal frontiers'. Admittedly, the French authorities in their explanatory memorandum made the point, at least implicity, that the amount of transfer traffic was substantially greater on intra-Community international routes terminating at Paris than on French domestic routes serving Paris. The French authorities, however, have failed to provide data to justify this argument which, if soundly based for each route in isolation, could justify the choice of national frontiers as the criterion.

The allocation of most intra-Community international air services to CDG airport alone appears all the less objective because not only French domestic routes but also many extra-Community international services, including medium-haul services, are operated concurrently at Orly and CDG airports by French or by non-Community airlines. A total of 27 destinations outside the Community, seven of them medium-haul destinations, are served both from and to Orly and CDG airports.

Although routes between Paris and Mediterranean destinations are chiefly assigned to Orly, routes to and from Italy, for no apparent reason, may be served only at CDG.