, Decision_act (EU) 1994/290

In forcesince 27 Apr 1994

As the Commission expressly pointed out in Decision 93/347/EEC of 28 May 1993 on the Viva Air case (2) not disputed by France, application of these provisions may retrict the general principle of freedom of access to Community routes and airports laid down in Article 3 (1) of the same Regulation. Any such restriction must, like every exception to such a principle, be interpreted strictly and be based on criteria which are not only non-discriminatory but also transparent, objective and constant over a certain period. It is for Member States to provide all the relevant grounds.

The provisions of the Decree in question must be examined against these criteria.

Firstly, Articles 3, 4 and 5 (first and second indents) of the abovementioned Decree of 6 December 1993 draw a distinction between air services to or from airports in metropolitan France and French overseas departments, which may be operated concurrently at Orly and CDG airports, on the one hand, and, on the other hand, intra-Community international air services other than scheduled air services to or from Spain, Greece and Portugal, which may only be operated at CDG airport. Article 4 lays down a general prohibition on the operation of intra-Community international air services at Orly airport. Article 5 of the Decree lays down three exceptions to this general prohibition, including scheduled air services to or from Spain, Greece and Portugal. Consequently, Community carriers may not perform consecutive cabotage services between Orly and the French provinces when they are an extension of or preliminary to services between Orly and Member States other than France, Portugal, Spain and Greece.