17 This is similar to the practice of the parties in applying the 1971 agreement. At that time actual deliveries often varied from the quotas without compensatory deliveries taking place. It should be noticed that quotas unfilled or exceeded were discussed by the parties both during and at the end of a year. When actual deliveries varied by too much from the quota the party involved was to "take all appropriate steps to reach a balance by the end of a year" (Lindgens' letter to Hondorff of 22 July 1971).
From Hondorff's letter to the central office of 26 February 1974 it is clear that unfilled or exceeded quotas have continued to be discussed and that the repeated excesses of one party had led to consideration of the "reallocation" of certain third countries. This has, however, not taken place.
18 It is also clear that, even subsequent to the application of the agreement, the large excesses of one party were reduced over a short period by a reduction of that party's deliveries with an increase in the deliveries of the others even to the extent of their exceeding their own quotas.
19 (h) Changes proposed
Following the receipt of the Commission's statement of objections by the parties they maintained that an infringement of Article 85 (1) had not been proved, in that there was no evidence of cooperation to restrict competition and that in any case there was no appreciable restriction of competition. At the same time, they agreed to a "slight" alteration in their practice of cooperation by limiting the exchange of information to one monthly figure for deliveries in EEC and EFTA countries and by omitting the calculation on quota variation. However, it has been established that the previous form and that figures broken down for countries in the EEC and EFTA have been sent to the still-existing central office. The calculations relating to unfilled or exceeded quotas are, on the other hand, no longer made.
APPLICABILITY OF ARTICLE 85 (1)
20 Article 85 (1) prohibits as incompatible with the common market all agreements between undertakings and concerted practices which may affect trade between Member States and which have as their object or effect the prevention, restriction or distortion of competition within the common market.
Agreement and concerted practices