, Decision_act (EU) 1979/90

In forcesince 12 Dec 1978

32 Contrary to what ALM argues, Article 85 is applicable equally to its behaviour. In its judgment of 25 November 1971 in Case 22/71, Béguelin, the Court of Justice ruled that : "The fact that one of the undertakings which are parties to the Agreement is situate in a third country does not prevent application of that provision since the Agreement is operative on the territory of the common market" ((1971) ECR 949, 959). The notification and quota system extended to the whole territory of the common market and ALM collaborated in setting up and operating it.

33 (d) Appreciability of the effect

Contrary to what is contended by the parties, their cooperation has appreciably restricted competition and affected trade between Member States.

34 In 1976, the parties produced 2 089 tonnes of white lead pigment for the paint industry. In the same year, Western European consumption of the principal substitute, titanium oxide, amounted, if one considers only those paints for which titanium oxide and white lead come into competition, to 37 520 tonnes. Sales of zinc white amounted to about 3 000 tonnes ; the market share of white lead in 1976 was thus 4 79 %. A parallel evaluation of the market as described in paragraph 5 hereof for 1971 (the year in which the agreement was concluded) and 1973 (the year in which it was replaced by a concerted practice), reveals higher market shares, namely 8 77 % and 5 79 %.

35 The foregoing calculation is, however, incomplete. In fact, it does not take account of the fact that, as the parties have stressed on several occasions, white lead has certain specialized uses, such that, despite its appreciably higher price, it remains an important product for which, indeed, substitutes in certain limited fields of application can only be found with difficulty. The calculation also takes no account of the fact that the white lead producers themselves manufacture or market considerable quantities of substitute products, both for pigment in paint and, especially, for stabilizing agents. This production must not be ignored in evaluating the economic importance of the parties and of their cooperation.

  • Judgment of the Court of 25 November 1971. Béguelin Import Co. v S.A.G.L. Import Export.Decision

    25 Nov 1971 · 61971CJ0022