36 Furthermore, as the only white lead manufacturers in the Community, the parties were convinced that they could curb the decline in prices through cooperation involving only white lead and not the substitute products which they produce themselves too. Their cooperation in the white lead industry was designed to have a real impact on the market, and indeed it achieved this, though perhaps not to the desired extent.
37 These factors lead to a much higher estimation of the economic importance of the white lead market, despite its now smaller turnover, than the one presented by the parties, and to the conclusion that the restriction of competition sought and achieved by the parties must be regarded as appreciable. This is confirmed by the general economic importance of the three parties together, their aggregate sales being far above the threshold of 50 million units of account set by the Commission in its de minimis notice of 19 December 1977 (1).
38 The fact that sales of white lead have been declining over a number of years and that production capacity is far from fully employed offers no reason for ignoring the effects this information and quota system had on the market. Though the cooperation was motivated by a steadily shrinking market, the fact remains that the conditions of Article 85 (1) are fulfilled.
INAPPLICABILITY OF ARTICLE 85 (3)
39 Exemption under Article 85 (3) cannot be considered, as the cooperation was not notified to the Commission and is not within the classes of agreements exempted from notification by Article 4 (2) of Regulation No 17.
APPLICABILITY OF ARTICLE 3 OF REGULATION No 17
40 The Commission has grounds for finding, pursuant to Article 3 of Regulation No 17, that ALM, Hondorff and Lindgens have, since the beginning of 1971, been infringing Article 85 (1) in that, on the basis of an agreement made on 1 January 1971, which continued to operate in practice after its formal termination at the end of 1972, they have exchanged monthly figures concerning deliveries of white lead, broken down by country of destination, including the Community countries, established quotas for export deliveries and, on the basis of the figures exchanged, calculated monthly variations from these quotas.