3. DESCRIPTION OF THE REQUESTED DEROGATION › 3.2. Identification of the adequacy concern › 3.2.4. Report pursuant to Article 24(3) of the Electricity Regulation, Decision_act (EU) 2026/341

In forcesince 11 Aug 2025
(55)

On 22 April 2025, the Polish TSO published a report in response to ACER’s opinion on the differences between the NRAA and ERAA 2023 [Available at https://www.pse.pl/documents/20182/51490/250422_Opinion_response.pdf.]. In its report, the Polish TSO made the following points.

On the differences in assumptions on cross-zonal exchanges, the simplified approach applied to regional modelling has a limited impact on the NRAA results. The NRAA applies an approach to import assumptions that is consistent with the cross-border participation methodology (Article 26(11)(a) of the Electricity Regulation) [Available at https://www.acer.europa.eu/sites/default/files/documents/Individual%20Decisions/ACER%20Decision%2036-2020%20on%20cross-border%20participation_XBP%20CM_0.pdf.]. The divergence in export assumptions is justified by the fact that Poland is primarily an importing bidding zone, and modelling exports in the NRAA would merely reduce RES curtailments without enhancing the economic viability of existing plants. Consequently, the NRAA export assumptions would not affect the capacity mix or significantly alter adequacy risks.

The divergence in assumptions on capacity resources is due to the different timing of input collection for both studies (the first half of 2024 for the NRAA and the end of 2022 for ERAA 2023).

On the differences in the modelling of capacity resources, the EVA calculations in the NRAA constitute a more accurate and representative approach than that used in the ERAA. On the divergence in demand response and storage assumptions, the Polish TSO states that its calculations show no investment decisions for storage before 2029, and that market-driven deployment of storage would be expected from 2036 onwards. On demand response, the Polish TSO explains that in contrast to ERAA 2023, the NRAA also models implicit demand response. The divergence in patterns of planned maintenance of power plants is more in line with real-life observations than those considered in the ERAA 2023.