84 5. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID › 5.1. EXISTENCE OF STATE AID › 5.1.1. MEASURE 1: REDUCED LEVEL OF THE FINANCIAL GUARANTEES › 5.1.1.1. Selective economic advantage › Conclusion on existence of selective economic advantage, Decision_act (EU) 2018/118

In forcesince 31 Aug 2017cited 1×

The arguments of the Spanish authorities and Iberpotash that the public authorities did not provide to Iberpotash any advantage or preferential treatment as a result of a rigorous application of the relevant rules cannot be accepted since it has been established above that these decisions of public authorities led to a level of the financial guarantees which was lower than normally required. Further, the argument that the Catalan legislation was in fact stricter than similar rules at the State level or in other regions of Spain is not relevant since such costs are site-specific and the rules concerning the financial guarantees to be established by Iberpotash which had to be respected were the ones applicable in Catalonia where the waste heaps were located. Iberpotash was allowed by the public authorities to maintain lower financial guarantees than was normally required by the Catalan legislation applicable to it and thus received a selective advantage in the form of lower bank fees for the reduced guarantees as compared to other operators in a similar position.

  • Judgment of the General Court (Second Chamber) of 16 January 2020. Iberpotash, SA v European Commission.Decision

    It follows from the foregoing that the Commission did not make an error of assessment by finding, in recitals 82 to 85 of the contested decision, that Measure 1 conferred a selective advantage on the applicant.

    16 Jan 2020 · 62018TJ0257