Both the Spanish authorities and Iberpotash confirm in their submissions that the Higher Court of Justice of Catalonia has considered that the guarantee for El Cogulló was insufficient. They attempt at mitigating the court's judgment by claiming that: (i) the court acknowledged that, at least partly, the situation dates back to 1929, (ii) the court admitted that it has no conclusive proof, and (iii) the court allegedly did not find any concrete infringement of a particular legal norm. However, none of these arguments with respect to the judgment affect the finding of insufficiency of the guarantee. The fact that the Spanish authorities in fact reviewed the guarantee amount following the confirmation of the judgment in appeal and submitted it for approval to the court confirms the relevance of the judgment. In addition, the judgment of 11 October 2011 explicitly refers to the relevant legislative provisions set out in Article 8(2) of Law 12/1981 and in Decree 202/1994.
65 5. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID › 5.1. EXISTENCE OF STATE AID › 5.1.1. MEASURE 1: REDUCED LEVEL OF THE FINANCIAL GUARANTEES › 5.1.1.1. Selective economic advantage › Evidence that Ibepotash's guarantee amounts are lower than required, Decision_act (EU) 2018/118
In forcesince 31 Aug 2017
- celex=31994R0202