73 5. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID › 5.1. EXISTENCE OF STATE AID › 5.1.1. MEASURE 1: REDUCED LEVEL OF THE FINANCIAL GUARANTEES › 5.1.1.1. Selective economic advantage › Evidence that Ibepotash's guarantee amounts are lower than required, Decision_act (EU) 2018/118

In forcesince 31 Aug 2017

Finally, the ERF Study analyses the impact of the planned extraction and commercialisation of the salt in the heaps based on the newly announced Plan Phoenix that started to be implemented in 2012. Taking into account various scenarios as regards the expected production of potash and salt in the future (including the most ambitious plans of Iberpotash to sell annually 1,5 million tonnes of salt), the ERF Study concludes that under any of those scenarios, the Plan Phoenix would only slow down but not stop the continued annual growth of the total waste material accumulated at Iberpotash's sites. In the most optimistic scenario, the Plan Phoenix would lead to a reduction of the total waste material deposited on the heaps to 1213 kt per year (compared to 1979 kt per year without the Plan Phoenix). Therefore, while the Plan Phoenix has an appreciable impact by reducing the annual waste accumulation by up to almost 40 %, the ERF Study considers that the Plan Phoenix cannot be considered as a self-sufficient restoration measure, but rather as a mitigating factor, since it will at most lead to slow down of the growth of the existing waste heaps but not to their elimination.