62 5. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID › 5.1. EXISTENCE OF STATE AID › 5.1.1. MEASURE 1: REDUCED LEVEL OF THE FINANCIAL GUARANTEES › 5.1.1.1. Selective economic advantage › Evidence that Ibepotash's guarantee amounts are lower than required, Decision_act (EU) 2018/118

In forcesince 31 Aug 2017cited 1×

Most importantly, the Higher Court of Justice of Catalonia (Tribunal Superior de Justicia de Cataluña) ruled on 11 October 2011 that the amount of the financial guarantee for Iberpotash's Cogulló waste heap at its site of Balsareny/Sallent amounting to EUR 585153 was lower than required. The judgment rules that the amount of the guarantee does not respect the legal and regulatory parameters set by the national legislation, referring in particular to Article 8(2) of Law 12/1981 and Decree 202/1994. The judgment states that, even in the absence of any conclusive proof (‘una prueba concluyemente determinada’) of the correct amount of the guarantee, the Court is able to conclude that the guarantee amount set to only EUR 585153 is clearly not in line with these legal provisions. The court thus declares the guarantee as insufficient and not in line with the applicable legislation and orders the Spanish authorities to set a new level of the financial guarantee. This judgment was fully confirmed on appeal by the judgment of the Supreme Court (Tribunal Supremo) of 9 July 2014. Finally, as noted by the Spanish authorities, by its finding of 14 December 2016, the Higher Court of Justice of Catalonia confirmed that a newly proposed amount of EUR 6979471,83 for the whole site at Balsareny/Sallent was adequate.

  • Judgment of the General Court (Second Chamber) of 16 January 2020. Iberpotash, SA v European Commission.Decision

    In that regard, the applicant has not succeeded in showing, by its arguments, that the Commission erred in taking that judgment into account in its assessment. Indeed, as the Commission rightly observes, the national court, which is …

    16 Jan 2020 · 62018TJ0257