99 7. ASSESSMENT › 7.1. Existence of aid › Economic advantage (1), Decision_act (EU) 2015/1470

In forcesince 30 Mar 2015cited 1×

In light of this conclusion, it cannot be maintained, as the claimants do, that the Tribunal found Romania’s decision to comply with Union State aid rules by revoking EGO 24 not to have been in breach of the BIT, or that it did not award damages on that basis [The Tribunal concluded that the revocation of the EGO 24 incentives violated the claimants’ legitimate expectations before it even considered the reasonableness or transparency of Romania’s actions (Award, paragraphs 725, 726; reasonableness and transparency were only considered in paragraphs 727 et seq. and 837 et seq., respectively). There is thus no basis for maintaining, as the claimants suggest, that the Tribunal’s finding of a breach of the BIT was conditioned on the unreasonableness of keeping in place the investors’ obligations under EGO 24 or on the insufficient transparency of Romania’s actions.]. The Commission notes that in justifying its decision to award compensation for increased prices and the loss of the ability to stockpile, as well as lost profits, the Tribunal referred only to damages incurred by the claimants as a result of the revocation of the EGO 24 incentives [Award, paragraphs 953, 961, 971, 984, 1016, 1020, 1136.]. Notably, the Tribunal did not refer to, or award additional damages on the basis of, its finding that Romania acted unreasonably in maintaining the investors’ obligations under EGO 24 and failed to act transparently.

  • Judgment of the General Court (Second Chamber, Extended Composition) of 18 June 2019. European Food SA and Others v European Commission.Decision

    The Commission also noted, in recital 99 of the contested decision, that, ‘in justifying its decision to award compensation for increased prices and the loss of the ability to stockpile, as well as lost profits, the [arbitral tribunal …

    18 Jun 2019 · 62015TJ0624