100 7. ASSESSMENT › 7.1. Existence of aid › Economic advantage (2): damages and State aid, Decision_act (EU) 2015/1470

In forcesince 30 Mar 2015

The presence of an advantage is, contrary to the submission of the claimants, furthermore not precluded by the fact that the payment of the compensation awarded to the complainants by the Tribunal through the implementation or execution of the Award entails a payment of compensation for damages. The central question in this regard is whether the principles laid down in the CJEU’s Asteris [Joined Cases 106/87 to 120/87 Asteris EU:C:1988:457.] judgment are applicable to the case at hand. In its judgment in Asteris, the CJEU set out that State aid ‘is fundamentally different in its legal nature from damages which the competent national authorities may be ordered to pay to individuals in compensation for the damage they have caused to those individuals.’ [Joined Cases 106/87 to 120/87 Asteris EU:C:1988:457, paragraph 23.] The claimants argue that the present case falls squarely under this case-law, and that any attempt by the Commission to distinguish the Asteris case from the one at hand is unconvincing. The Commission disagrees with this position.

  • Judgment of the Court (Fifth Chamber) of 27 September 1988. Asteris AE and others v Hellenic Republic and European Economic Community.Decision

    27 Sep 1988 · 61987CJ0106

  • case:eu=C-106/87
  • case:eu=C-120/87