In the opening decision, the Commission reached the preliminary conclusion that payment of the compensation awarded by the Tribunal to the claimants through the implementation or execution of the Award constitutes State aid within the meaning of Article 107(1) of the Treaty. This preliminary conclusion rests on the preliminary findings that:
the five claimants constitute one economic unit that must be qualified as an undertaking,
payment of the awarded compensation would grant the claimants an economic advantage not otherwise available on the market,
the presence of an advantage is not precluded by the fact that the compensation awarded by the Tribunal is designated as compensation for damages, since the Award does not fall within the scope of the Asteris case-law distinguishing damages from State aid,
the advantage granted is selective, since only the claimants would benefit from the measure,
the advantage is granted from state resources, since the relevant payments would be made from the state budget, and the decision to grant the advantage is imputable to Romania, regardless of whether Romania implemented the Award voluntarily or on the order of a court,
payment of the compensation awarded to the claimants distorts competition and affects trade between Member States.