68 5. COMMENTS FROM INTERESTED PARTIES › Regarding the characterisation of the implementation/execution of the Award as new aid, Decision_act (EU) 2015/1470

In forcesince 30 Mar 2015

The claimants further take issue with the characterisation of the implementation/execution of the Award as new aid. They note that the only events that took place after Romania’s accession were the adoption of the Award itself and the execution thereof. Romania’s execution in particular is said to be a mere automatic consequence of the Award, rather than the result of a distinct decision. The relevant points in time were, according to the claimants, the enactment of EGO 24, the issuance of PICs to the claimants, or at the latest the conclusion of the BIT. The claimants also rely on case-law and Commission practice on state guarantees (according to which the relevant point in time is when the guarantee is given, not when it is invoked or payments issued) to argue that where compensation is paid based on a commitment included in an international agreement, the date of the conclusion of that agreement should be considered decisive.