The Tribunal further decided that Romania had to pay damages to the claimants [Award, paragraphs 875 et seq.]. In total, the Tribunal awarded the claimants RON 376433229 plus interest. The damages are made up as follows: the Tribunal found that Romania had to pay the claimants RON 85,1 million [This amount is calculated for imports made during 22 February 2005 and 31 March 2009.] in damages for the increased cost of sugar (for the import of which the claimants had to pay customs duties after the revocation of the Raw Materials Facility), RON 17,5 million [See footnote 28.] in damages for the increased cost of raw materials other than sugar and PET [The claimants asked for compensation for the increased cost of PET. However, the Tribunal rejected this claims on the basis that the claimants had never in fact benefited from the Raw Materials Facility with respect to PET imports.], RON 18,1 million [This amount is calculated on the basis of custom duties charged on imported sugar and that would have been avoided, if the claimant had had the opportunity to stockpile sugar before the envisaged expiry of the EGO (i.e. 1 April 2009). The benchmark is based on stockpiles in 2004/2005.] in damages for the loss of the ability to stockpile sugar at lower prices, and RON 255,7 million [Lost profits are calculated over the period 2004-2008 for loss of market shares of soft drinks and other products that did contain sugar. The claim is that after the revocation of the EGO incentives, the costs increased leading to higher prices and thus to lower market shares.] in damages for lost profit deriving from lost sales of finished goods. In addition, the Tribunal ordered Romania to pay interest (ROBOR plus 5 %), calculated from 1 March 2007 with respect to the increased cost of sugar and other raw materials, from 1 November 2009 with respect to loss of ability to stockpile sugar, and from 1 May 2008 with respect to lost profits. On the date of the Award, the principal and interest due to the claimants amounted to RON 791882452, as illustrated in the table.
Damages and interest as awarded to the claimants by the Award
Damages awarded | Amount (in RON) | Interest calculated from
Increased cost of sugar | 85100000 | 1 March 2007
Increased cost of raw materials other than sugar or PET | 17500000 | 1 March 2007
Lost opportunity to stockpile sugar | 18133229 | 1 November 2009
Lost profits on the sale of finished goods | 255700000 | 1 May 2008
TOTAL | 376433229 |
Total including interest on 11 December 2013:
RON 791882452