The claimants further maintain that the implementation or execution of the Award would fall squarely under the Asteris case-law. They argue that the rationale behind the Asteris case-law, as well as such cases as Denkavit [Case 61/79 Amministrazione delle finanze dello Stato v Denkavit italiana EU:C:1980:100.] and ThyssenKrupp [Commission Decision 2008/408/EC of 20 November 2007 on the State aid C 36/A/06 (ex NN 38/06) implemented by Italy in favour of ThyssenKrupp, Cementir and Nuove Terni Industrie Chimiche (OJ L 144, 4.6.2008, p. 37).], is that payment of damages is not within the discretion of Member States, so that it cannot qualify as State aid. Romania’s commitments under the BIT are further claimed to be an expression of general rules of liability to which the Asteris case-law applies. Regarding the Commission’s argument that Asteris does not apply to damages awarded on the basis of intra-EU BITs considered incompatible with Union law, the claimants maintain that any such incompatibility would not render the Award granted on the basis of such a BIT void. Implementation or execution of the Award could furthermore not be seen as granting State aid ‘by the back door’, as the Award does not reinstate the abolished EGO 24 scheme; rather, the Award is said to grant damages for Romania’s autonomous decision to, inter alia, maintain an unreasonable burden imposed on the claimants.
61 5. COMMENTS FROM INTERESTED PARTIES › Regarding the characterisation of the implementation/execution of the Award as State aid, Decision_act (EU) 2015/1470
In forcesince 30 Mar 2015
Judgment of the Court of 27 March 1980. Amministrazione delle finanze dello Stato v Denkavit italiana Srl.Decision
27 Mar 1980 · 61979CJ0061
- case:eu=C-61/79
- celex=31961D0079