6. COMMENTS FROM FRANCE ON THE COMMENTS FROM THIRD PARTIES › 6.1. In response to UOP’s comments, Decision_act (EU) 2009/157

In forcesince 16 Jul 2008
(96)

Concerning Axens’s autonomy from IFP, France states first that, according to established Community case law, the ownership structure of the capital of a subsidiary is not, by itself, a sufficient criterion for determining whether that subsidiary may or may not be regarded as enjoying economic autonomy from its parent company. Despite being wholly owned by IFP, Axens is totally independent in the market. This independence is confirmed by several items of evidence:

(a)

Axens has an autonomous decision-making process and a financial and human organisation of its own;

(b)

Axens sets freely its commercial policy and its sales targets and gross margins;

(c)

Axens acts in the refining and petrochemicals market in its own name and on its own behalf and has the power to contract without IFP’s prior consent;

(d)

Axens enjoys financial autonomy from IFP within the limits of the reserved powers specified in its articles of association and is not the sole distributor of IFP technologies.