3. REASONS FOR INITIATING THE FORMAL INVESTIGATION PROCEDURE, Decision_act (EU) 2009/157

In forcesince 16 Jul 2008
(36)

First, the Commission considered that the conditions laid down in its earlier decisions were no longer met. As a reminder, its earlier decisions were based on:

(a)

the fact that no direct aid was granted to IFP insofar as IFP was a non-profit-making research centre not engaged in a commercial activity. In accordance with the first paragraph of point 2.4 of the 1996 R & D framework, public financing of R & D activities by public non-profit-making higher education or research establishments is not normally covered by Article 87(1) of the Treaty;

(b)

the fact that no indirect aid was granted to firms acquiring the findings of IFP studies insofar as the potential advantage resulting from the transfer of the findings was available without discrimination to all firms. In this connection the Commission had noted that IFP transferred its research findings to firms in four different ways: dissemination in the public domain, services invoiced at cost price, collaborative research and sale of licences. In the latter two cases, the Commission considered that, while firms did not bear the total costs of research, this advantage was available without discrimination to all firms, irrespective of nationality;

(c)

the fact that no indirect aid was granted to firms in which IFP held shares insofar as IFP collaborated with those firms on the same terms and conditions as with other firms in which it did not hold shares. Because of the involvement of other shareholders, IFP’s minority shareholdings in firms active in its research field and its collaboration with those firms on the same terms and conditions as with other firms in which it did not hold shares, the Commission concluded that the firms in question did not receive more favourable treatment.