5. COMMENTS FROM THIRD PARTIES › 5.1. Content of the complaint behind the initiation of the procedure, Decision_act (EU) 2009/157

In forcesince 16 Jul 2008
(70)

The complainant takes the view that the current financing of the activities of IFP and Axens by the State, which has not been notified to the Commission and is not covered by any of the Commission’s earlier decisions, constitutes unlawful State aid. It stresses in this connection the factual differences between the findings of the Commission’s earlier decisions and the current situation in which IFP and Axens find themselves:

the subsidiary Axens is a commercial entity,

Axens has exclusive or preferential access to IFP’s services and research results,

IFP holds 100 % of Axens’s share capital,

in the market for technologies, most operators, including the complainant, are unsubsidised. The subsidised activities of the IFP/Axens entity lead to price distortion.