45 4. COMMENTS FROM FRANCE ON THE INITIATION OF THE FORMAL INVESTIGATION PROCEDURE › 4.1. On the background to the current procedure, Decision_act (EU) 2009/157

In forcesince 16 Jul 2008

Regarding the changes introduced subsequently of which the Commission was not informed, France provides the following information. First, according to France, the 100 % takeover of Prosernat and Axens by IFP at the end of 2001 could not be attributed to a choice on the part of IFP insofar as it was the deed of independent players. France points out, moreover, that, in its letter D/52473 of 19 June 2001, the Commission considered as a guarantee of non-discrimination the fact that IFP holds at least the majority of the shares in the new entity. Secondly, France maintains that, the agreements between IFP and Prosernat being similar to the agreements between IFP and Axens, it did not deem it necessary to forward them to the Commission. Lastly, France felt it was unnecessary to transmit to the Commission the agreement between IFP and Beicip-Franlab insofar as it provided for total coverage of IFP’s costs.