5. COMMENTS FROM THIRD PARTIES › 5.1. Content of the complaint behind the initiation of the procedure, Decision_act (EU) 2009/157

In forcesince 16 Jul 2008
(71)

The complainant thus considers that IFP departs significantly from the model of a public non-profit-making research establishment, as referred to in point 2.4 of the 1996 R & D framework, in the area of the commercial activities of its subsidiary Axens. On the contrary, in its view IFP and Axens constitute a single economic entity which acts in the market in direct competition with other operators. According to the complainant, several elements indicate that IFP and Axens are to be considered a single economic entity and hence an undertaking within the meaning of Article 87(1) of the Treaty:

IFP holds 100 % of Axens’s share capital,

IFP behaves as an active shareholder by taking part in the definition of its subsidiaries’ strategy,

the staff of Axens and IFP visit potential customers together,

Axens uses its name in connection with IFP’s technologies (as can be seen from Axens’s logo, which incorporates that of IFP).