60 4. COMMENTS FROM FRANCE ON THE INITIATION OF THE FORMAL INVESTIGATION PROCEDURE › 4.4. On the existence of State aid, Decision_act (EU) 2009/157

In forcesince 16 Jul 2008

In the case of the refining and petrochemicals market, France considers that the payments made by Axens for the work placed at its disposal by IFP are equivalent to market terms and conditions. To this financial compensation, France adds the expenditure incurred by Axens in carrying out supplementary tasks needed for the exploitation of the research work and the additional costs borne by Axens for using technologies and products other than those of IFP. In France’s view, the high share of its turnover devoted to research activities is a strong indicator of the absence of any competitive advantage derived by Axens from the research work carried out on its behalf by IFP. France provides evidence to show that the amounts spent by Axens on its research activities are much higher than the average for the sector.