53 4. COMMENTS FROM FRANCE ON THE INITIATION OF THE FORMAL INVESTIGATION PROCEDURE › 4.3. On the distinction between IFP and its subsidiaries, Decision_act (EU) 2009/157

In forcesince 16 Jul 2008

Thirdly, France tenders evidence to demonstrate the autonomy of IFP’s subsidiaries. Each subsidiary devises its own strategy and has it validated by its management board, which is not composed solely of IFP representatives. Contracts between IFP and its subsidiaries respect the ordinary-law rules on regulated agreements, hence the IFP representative does not take part in the voting on matters pertaining to the said contracts. Each subsidiary has its own committees and enjoys complete managerial autonomy subject to shareholder control, which is exercised through standard reporting mechanisms. In addition, IFP and its subsidiaries have hierarchically and geographically independent financial and accounting departments with different information and management systems. Lastly, IFP’s subsidiaries decide freely on the products and services they market. In this respect, Axens is free to accept or refuse the work presented by IFP, and France gives several examples of processes where Axens supplements its research requirements with other contractual relationships.