Fifthly, UOP suggests that the Commission should bear in mind the specificity of the market for process technology licences when it seeks to establish a correspondence between the R & D activities of the IFP/Axens entity and the categories of research defined in Annex I to the 1996 R & D framework. This specificity is due, in its opinion, to the fact that the IFP/Axens entity and its competitors market, not a product or a service, but a process. According to UOP, the fact that the industry habitually uses the term ‘R & D’ to designate the development of a marketable process must not make the Commission lose sight of the fact that such development is downstream of R & D activities as defined in the 1996 R & D framework. In this respect UOP argues that R & D for the refining and petrochemicals processing industries can be categorised according to three stages:
a fundamental research stage during which new materials and process concepts are developed and tested up to proof of principle [Also known as ‘proof of concept’.] demonstration;
a process and material development stage during which the materials and process concepts discovered are developed for commercial application;
an application development stage during which tools are built, enabling reproducible performance forecasting and materials manufacturing so as to offer the product in a competitive context.