98 6. COMMENTS FROM FRANCE ON THE COMMENTS FROM THIRD PARTIES › 6.1. In response to UOP’s comments, Decision_act (EU) 2009/157

In forcesince 16 Jul 2008

Secondly, given that in accordance with the first subparagraph of point 2.4 of the 1996 R & D framework the resources transferred by the State to IFP do not constitute State aid, France contests UOP’s assertion that those resources [According to UOP, this amount came to EUR 555 million over the last three years, while according to France it seems to correspond to the sums received by IFP by way of the budget allocation for the years 2003, 2004 and 2005 (being in reality exactly EUR 507 million).] constitute operating aid.