203 7. ASSESSMENT › 7.5. Compatibility of the aid › 7.5.5. Incentive effect, Decision_act (EU) 2009/157

In forcesince 16 Jul 2008

Seventhly, contrary to what UOP maintains, the Commission considers that the State support for IFP and its subsidiary Axens is not, by virtue either of its nature or its scale, liable to impair the dynamic of the refining technologies market. First of all, the Commission notes that supply in this market is highly differentiated, while the number of customers is limited. A world round-up of refining or petrochemical units in operation in 2005 thus shows that there were seven types of process. Moreover, customers choose a technology in the light of various criteria, some of which, such as the cost of the associated installation and the profitability of the investment, while they are regarded as critical, are completely exogenous to the aided research projects. Lastly, the Commission observes that certain competitors of IFP and Axens have a strong competitive position which should enable them to maintain their R & D plans in this market. UOP thus has a world market share corresponding to 57 % in value terms of existing licensed refining units, whereas the share held by IFP and Axens comes to 7 %.