126 7. ASSESSMENT › 7.1. Existence of State aid › 7.1.1. Identification of potential beneficiaries, Decision_act (EU) 2009/157

In forcesince 16 Jul 2008

On the question of how IFP and its subsidiaries are perceived in the relevant markets, the Commission considers that several elements point to IFP and the subsidiaries concerned having a common presence and a common image in the eyes of their customers and competitors. Besides the words ‘IFP Group Technologies’ on Axens’s and Prosernat’s logos, there are direct links between the Internet sites of the subsidiaries concerned and the Internet site of IFP. Axens and Prosernat refer on their Internet sites to IFP’s R & D efforts in their fields of activity [Extract from Axens’s Internet site: ‘Axens is a refining, petrochemical and natural gas market focused company offering market-leading products including processes, catalysts, adsorbents and equipment, backed by nearly fifty years of R & D and industrial success’. Extract from Prosernat’s Internet site: ‘The association of all the scientific skills and development know-how of Prosernat’s mother company IFP, with Prosernat’s industrial experience brings a unique opportunity to turn innovative ideas into an industrial reality’.]. Beicip-Franlab’s Bahrain office calls itself ‘IFP Middle East Consulting’. And IFP and Axens participate jointly in various conferences [See, for example, single IFP/Axens representative at the 10th Congress of the Société Française de Génie des Procédés (http://inpact.inp-toulouse.fr/SFGP/pageaccueil.html).]. The Commission has also noted several references to a single entity, IFP/Axens, in advertisements and publications [See, for example, ‘Liquefin, developed and commercialised by IFP-Axens’, in ‘New liquefaction process promises lower costs’, Oil & Gas Journal, 19.8.2002, ‘IFP is the world’s second largest process licensor in refining and petrochemicals (via its subsidiary Axens) and is an internationally recognised center of excellence in exploration and production’. www.tmcnet.com, 15.12.2005.] and on the Internet sites of players in the industry [See, for example, on the site www.topsoe.com, references to units licensed by ‘IFP/Axens’; reference to ‘IFP (Axens)’ on the site of Nexant, a consultancy firm in the energy sector (http://nexant.ecnext.com/coms2/summary_0255-3019_ITM); see also the presentation of the GTL Eni-IFP/Axens project at http://gcceu-conference.epu.ntua.gr].