116 7. ASSESSMENT › 7.1. Existence of State aid › 7.1.1. Identification of potential beneficiaries, Decision_act (EU) 2009/157

In forcesince 16 Jul 2008

However, in its decision to initiate the procedure the Commission, for the reasons set out in recital 37 of this Decision, partly called this analysis into question. It found, inter alia, that, through its subsidiaries Axens, Beicip-Franlab and Prosernat, IFP was engaged in economic activities in, respectively, the market for refining and petrochemicals technologies, the market for oilfield operation consultancy services and the contract development of oilfield software, and the market for gas treatment and sulphur recovery technologies (hereinafter called ‘the relevant markets’). Consequently, it must be examined whether or not the public subsidy paid to IFP amounts to State aid in the relevant markets.