101 6. COMMENTS FROM FRANCE ON THE COMMENTS FROM THIRD PARTIES › 6.1. In response to UOP’s comments, Decision_act (EU) 2009/157

In forcesince 16 Jul 2008

Fourthly, according to UOP, the right of first refusal confers an advantage on Axens, which allegedly does not pay the market price for such a right. France stresses the importance of assessing the economic impact of the remuneration paid by Axens to IFP as a whole. Besides dividends, the components of this overall remuneration (consisting in the remuneration for the right of first refusal and the royalties paid under the framework licensing and product licensing agreements) were determined in 2001 according to an economic logic. This logic is intended to ensure that Axens does not derive any economic advantage from its relationship with IFP and to guarantee a suitable, steady return from year to year for IFP, sufficiently independent of the combination resulting from Axens’s sales at any given time so as to avoid any risk to IFP from excessive variations in resources.