96 VII. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID MEASURE › Recovery, Decision_act (EU) 2005/77

In forcesince 30 Mar 2004

Arguments similar to those in recital 37 on the consequences of recovery for the Gibraltar economy were used by the Government of Gibraltar in an attempt to prevent publication of the decision to open the formal investigation procedure [Joined Cases T-195/01 R and T-207/01 Gibraltar v Commission, paragraphs 94 to 105.]. They have not materialised. It is far from certain that they would do so as a result of a recovery order in this case. The Commission also notes that the arguments on the impact of recovery on the Gibraltar economy encompassed both the Qualifying Companies and the Exempt Companies regimes. However, since the Government of Gibraltar made its observations, the threat of recovery has diminished to the extent that following the annulment of the Commission's decision initiating the formal State aid investigation procedure [Joined Cases T-195/01 and T-207/01, paragraph 115.], the original 1967 Exempt Companies legislation is now under investigation as an existing aid scheme. There can be no recovery order in respect of this legislation and consequently the impact forecast by the Government of Gibraltar, to the extent it materialises at all, will be reduced. In any event, the Commission cannot allow such hypothetical considerations to impede the restoration, as far as possible, of the competitive situation that existed before the implementation of an illegal aid measure.

  • Judgment of the Court of First Instance (Second Chamber, extended composition) of 30 April 2002. Government of Gibraltar v Commission of theDecision

    30 Apr 2002 · 62001TJ0195