42 V. COMMENTS FROM CHARLES A. GOMEZ & CO., Decision_act (EU) 2005/77

In forcesince 30 Mar 2004

The recourse to Article 87(3)(a) of the Treaty cannot be restricted to areas where the standard of living is already low or where there is already serious unemployment. The principle of Article 87(3)(a) must also apply in the interest of preventing unemployment and poverty. When the Qualifying Company legislation was enacted, Gibraltar was faced with 20 years of economic sanctions by Spain and the imminent closure of the Royal Navy Dockyard. Faced with the option of poverty, unemployment and emigration, Gibraltar found an alternative source of prosperity by establishing the Gibraltar Finance Centre, to which the Qualifying Companies legislation is a major contributor. The European interest cannot link acceptance of poverty and unemployment by ruling out the application of Article 87(3)(a) of the Treaty to this situation when viable alternatives are available. Unlike other major financial centres, the Gibraltar centre was established through necessity. This necessity, self defence and the duty to mitigate damage caused by others all justify the Qualifying Companies legislation.