73 VII. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID MEASURE › Existing aid or illegal aid, Decision_act (EU) 2005/77

In forcesince 30 Mar 2004

Even if, as the United Kingdom maintains, some Member States’ banking laws and exchange controls, at the time, prevented the use of such offshore tax advantages, the existence of the tax benefits would nevertheless still have strengthened the position of Qualifying Companies in markets not subject to such restrictions compared with their competitors in other Member States. In this respect, the Government of Gibraltar has advanced essentially the same arguments used in its pleadings before the Court of First Instance. The Court rejected these arguments against the Commission's provisional classification of the Qualifying Companies legislation and concluded that such ‘general arguments are not capable of establishing that the 1983 tax scheme must, owing to its intrinsic characteristics, be classified as an existing aid scheme’ [See Joined Cases T-195/01 and T-207/01.]. The Court also rejected parallels drawn with the Irish Corporation Tax case [OJ C 395, 18.12.1998, p. 14.] on the grounds that the factual and legal circumstances were quite different [Joined Cases T-195/01 and T-207/01, paragraphs 120 and 123.]. The Commission therefore sees no grounds on which to change its view.

  • Judgment of the Court of First Instance (Second Chamber, extended composition) of 30 April 2002. Government of Gibraltar v Commission of theDecision

    30 Apr 2002 · 62001TJ0195