49 VI. COMMENTS FROM THE UNITED KINGDOM › Regional specificity, Decision_act (EU) 2005/77

In forcesince 30 Mar 2004

The sole fact that the Qualifying Companies regime is a feature of Gibraltar legislation that has no application in the rest of the United Kingdom cannot give rise to the element of selectivity required by Article 87(1) of the Treaty. Gibraltar is a separate jurisdiction from the rest of the United Kingdom for tax purposes, with autonomy in relation to tax matters. It is not the case that any divergence between taxation laws applicable in Gibraltar and those applying in the rest of the United Kingdom would automatically give rise to State aid. One jurisdiction within a Member State with autonomy in relation to taxation matters cannot create a State aid purely because a particular aspect of its taxation system results in a lower (or higher) level of taxation than that applicable to the rest of the Member State. If a tax measure is general within the relevant tax jurisdiction, it cannot be caught by Article 87(1) of the Treaty. To rule otherwise would be to call into question the tax raising and tax varying powers enjoyed by devolved and decentralised administrations across the Community. This would constitute a serious intervention in Member States’ constitutional arrangements.