28 IV. COMMENTS FROM THE GOVERNMENT OF GIBRALTAR › The Qualifying Companies legislation constitutes existing aid rather than illegal aid, Decision_act (EU) 2005/77

In forcesince 30 Mar 2004

The Commission's investigations should be subject to a limitation period. Thus, pursuant to Article 15 of Regulation (EC) No 659/1999, any individual aid granted under an aid scheme 10 years before the Commission takes action must be deemed to be existing aid. Applying that rule, the Commission should have regarded the Qualifying Companies legislation as an existing aid scheme. In any event, the Commission infringed the principles of legitimate expectations and of legal certainty by allowing an excessively long period to elapse after opening its investigation into the legislation. The preliminary investigation began on 12 February 1999, but the formal investigation procedure was not initiated until two and a half years later. The preliminary investigation was punctuated by long periods of inactivity by the Commission. Given that there was some doubts within the Commission as late as November 2000 as to the utility of opening the State aid procedure on the harmful measures identified by the Code of Conduct Group, it is reasonable to claim that the existing aid procedure should have been used.

  • celex=31999R0659