80 VII. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID MEASURE › Compatibility, Decision_act (EU) 2005/77

In forcesince 30 Mar 2004

The Qualifying Companies regime cannot be considered either to be a project of common European interest or to remedy a serious disturbance in the economy of a Member State, as referred to in Article 87(3)(b) of the Treaty. As the Government of Gibraltar has observed, the Commission and the Court of Justice interpret Article 87(3)(b) strictly as meaning that a serious disturbance must affect the whole economy of a Member State [See Joined cases T-132/96 and T-143/96, Freistaat and others v Commission, ECR [1999] II-3663, paragraphs 166, 167 and 168.]. The disturbance in question, the closure of the Naval Dockyard, did not disturb the whole of the United Kingdom's economy. Whilst the Commission notes the Government of Gibraltar's argument that Gibraltar is separated from the United Kingdom in constitutional, political, legislative, economic, fiscal and geographic terms, this does not alter the fact that for the purposes of the State aid rules, Gibraltar forms part of the United Kingdom, regardless of the unique scope of Article 299(4) of the Treaty. In any event, there are other areas of the Community which are also characterised by varying types and degrees of separation from the Member State of which they form part. None of these areas is treated as a Member State in its own right for the purposes of Article 87(3)(b). The parallels that the Government of Gibraltar draws with measures adopted in response to the bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE) crisis in the United Kingdom are not relevant. The BSE crisis was considered to be an exceptional occurrence and accordingly these measures fell within the scope of Article 87(2)(b) of the Treaty. There is no requirement that, for Article 87(2)(b) to apply, the exceptional occurrence must affect the whole of a Member State concerned.