It is highly unlikely that in 1984, any consideration was given by either the Government of Gibraltar or the United Kingdom Government to the possibility that the rules in question were in breach of the United Kingdom's State aid obligations. While it was clear at that time that a highly specific or sectoral tax advantage was capable of being State aid, the application of the State aid rules to more general company tax schemes, such as the Qualifying Companies regime, had been the subject of neither serious academic comment nor pronouncement by the Commission. It would be unreasonable to expect diligent businessmen to raise questions about the compliance of the measure with the State aid rules. They would have made business plans and altered their economic positions on the basis of the Qualifying Companies legislation and were entitled to assume that the tax benefits were lawful.
47 VI. COMMENTS FROM THE UNITED KINGDOM › Recovery of aid, Decision_act (EU) 2005/77
In forcesince 30 Mar 2004