84 VII. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID MEASURE › Recovery, Decision_act (EU) 2005/77

In forcesince 30 Mar 2004

The Government of Gibraltar's arguments to the effect that legitimate expectations have been created by the uncertainty of the scope of the State aid rules and the rarity or novelty of Commission action against tax measures, whether offshore in nature or not, must be rejected. Only in exceptional circumstances may a recipient of unlawful aid escape the obligation to repay such aid and it is for the national courts alone to assess the circumstances of the individual case [See for example Cases C-5/89 Commission v Germany [1990] ECR I-3437), T-67/94 Ladbroke Racing v Commission [1998] ECR II-1, T-459/93 Siemens v Commission (ECR [1995] II 1675.]. Similarly, as the publication of the Notice represented neither a policy statement by the Commission, nor, as the United Kingdom implies, a tightening of the application of the State aid rules, it cannot have created legitimate expectations [See footnote 23.]. The application of a Treaty rule to a specific situation for the first time cannot create a legitimate expectation in respect of the past. In any event, contrary to what the United Kingdom suggests, the differential tax treatment between resident and non-resident companies has played an important part in previous Commission State aid decisions [See, for example, Commission Decision 95/452/EC of 12 April 1995 on State aid in the form of tax concessions to undertakings operating in the Trieste Financial Services & Insurance Centre pursuant to Article 3 of Italian Law No 19 of 9 January 1991 on, OJ L 264, 7.11.1995, p. 30, recital 10.].

  • Decision_act (EU) 1995/452Law

  • Judgment of the Court of 20 September 1990. Commission of the European Communities v Federal Republic of Germany.Decision

    20 Sep 1990 · 61989CJ0005

  • Judgment of the Court of First Instance (Second Chamber) of 8 June 1995. Siemens SA v Commission of the European Communities.Decision

    8 Jun 1995 · 61993TJ0459

  • Judgment of the Court of First Instance (Second Chamber, extended composition) of 27 January 1998. Ladbroke Racing Ltd v Commission of the EDecision

    27 Jan 1998 · 61994TJ0067