100 VII. ASSESSMENT OF THE AID MEASURE › Recovery, Decision_act (EU) 2005/77

In forcesince 30 Mar 2004

The Court of Justice has consistently ruled that where a diligent businessman could have foreseen the adoption of a Community measure likely to affect his interests, he cannot rely on the principle of protection of legitimate expectations if the measure is adopted [See for example Case 265/85, Van den Bergh and Jurgens v Commission [1987] ECR, 1155, paragraph 44.]. Given the similarities between the Exempt Companies and Qualifying Companies regimes, it is hard to see how a diligent operator could have anticipated that the two regimes would be subject to different State aid procedures. The differences between the two schemes, rather than being inherent in their design, reflect the practice of the Gibraltar authorities to require those offshore companies with a physical presence in Gibraltar to pay tax, albeit at a low level. It is therefore reasonable to assume that a conscientious businessman, acting in good faith, could legitimately have believed that by opting for the less generous Qualifying Companies regime rather than the manifestly legal (in State aid terms, existing) Exempt Companies regime, he would also enter a regime whose legality was not in doubt. Accordingly, the Commission concludes that an order for recovery would, in the exceptional circumstances of this case, be contrary to a general principle of Community law.

  • Judgment of the Court of 11 March 1987. Van den Bergh en Jurgens BV and Van Dijk Food Products (Lopik) BV v Commission of the European CommuDecision

    11 Mar 1987 · 61985CJ0265

  • case:eu=C-265/85