Recital 99, Decision_act (EU) 2003/300

In forcesince 8 Oct 2002

With respect to the first issue, the confusion between copyright royalty and administration fee (the amalgamation of which results in the global license fee) restricts competition between collecting societies as regards the pricing for the licensing service provided to users(52). Where no distinction is made between those two elements, it becomes impossible to know which part of the license fee will be used to remunerate the right holder and which part thereof will serve to cover the administration costs incurred by the grantor society when providing and administering a multi-territory/multi-repertoire license. Among other things, this confusion shows that under the envisaged structure the societies would not take in consideration their actual administration costs when determining their administration fee vis-à-vis the users. This means that the part of the license fee that was meant to cover the administration costs of the grantor society would be arbitrarily determined and, as such, potentially excessive. In a scenario where the societies faced price competition, the concern would be somehow dissipated by the fact that the marginal cost of the service would tend to zero due to existence of competition between different societies. However, under the envisaged structure no price competition is made possible due to the obligation of aggregating all pre-determined national tariffs so as to arrive at a fixed global license fee.