Recital 67, Decision_act (EU) 2003/300

In forcesince 8 Oct 2002

In the present case, the model chosen by the parties for the simulcasting licensing structure results in the society granting a multi-repertoire/multi-territory license being limited in its freedom as to the amount of the global license fee it will charge to a user. In fact, the individual national tariffs determined by each of the participating collecting societies that contribute to the bundle of repertoires and territories being offered to a user through a single license will be imposed on the grantor society. This means that the global fee charged by the grantor society for a multi-repertoire/multi-territory license is to a large extent determined ab initio, which significantly reduces the competition in terms of price between EEA-based collecting societies. In this respect the participating EEA-based collecting societies will be offering exactly the same product, i.e. a neighbouring rights license covering the same repertoires and the same territories. As most of the third parties that submitted observations further to the publication of the Commission Notice pursuant to Article 19(3) of Regulation No 17 have emphasised(37), the degree of competition between the participating EEA-based collecting societies allowed for by the amendment to the Reciprocal Agreement could be undermined in practice if such competition did not extend to pricing and if all the participating societies ended up charging the same tariff for an identical license.