The fact that a collecting society is free to determine its national simulcasting tariff does not translate into actual price competition between societies because all the national tariffs will be aggregated such as to result in a unique global simulcasting tariff for a multi-territorial/multi-repertoire license, and this unique global tariff will be the same no matter which of the participating societies grants the license. Such freedom does therefore not translate into any useful advantage to a prospective user in terms of its ability to choose one provider on the basis of price differences. On the other hand, the fact that a society is free to negotiate with a prospective user on an individual basis the commercial terms of a license (apart from the global fee) may certainly, in some cases, introduce an element of price competition between societies. However, this will not always be the case. The possibility of enjoying rebates or discounts or advantageous payment terms will necessarily depend on the profile of the user. This means that for large-scale users a certain degree of price competition between societies may exist, depending on the different commercial terms offered to them by the various societies(38). However, this also means that for small- or medium-scale users no other terms besides the standard terms may be available. Given that the standard terms correspond to the undifferentiated simulcasting global tariff, the end result of the Reciprocal Agreement is that in most cases no price competition exists between the participating societies. Accordingly, a vast universe of users will be prevented from choosing a society on the basis of price differences for a multi-territory/multi-repertoire license.
Recital 69, Decision_act (EU) 2003/300
In forcesince 8 Oct 2002